Rewriting A Bad Story

Morning friend,

We spent the weekend in Pinetop, our summer cabin home. It was a beautiful weekend. Blue sunny skies. Cool breezes. But being away all winter does tell a story. The mice found refuge in our cabin on cold winter days and nights. I went to put on my slippers and found mouse droppings in the toes of my fur lined slippers. They must have made a warm bed for the mice those cold winters nights. I pictured them cozying down in the toes, all snug and warm and once I had that image in my head, I couldn’t put on the slippers all weekend. I’ll have to hang them upside down for a few days before I can wear them, just to make sure there are no more surprises.

Today’s question: A year ago I finally escaped an emotionally abusive relationship with a young man who proceeded to stalk me for 8 months after I told him to get lost. I was never dating him or even interested. He was needy and I was kind. As soon as I realized what he wanted (a codependent girl), I told him “absolutely not.”

Out of anger, he attempted to blackmail, emotionally abuse, and stalk me for 8 months. I am e-mailing you because although this was a long time ago and I have tried to work through the pain and fear with God and two different counselors, the pain has never gone away and the fear is something I carry into every relationship.

I want to be free, but sometimes all I see is this: 1, The older adults who didn’t believe that this was happening and didn’t raise a finger. 2, My roommate (who let him into my house), and my Christian community who gossiped, hated, or remained aloof instead of helping.

Often my emotional energy is exhausted from trying to take care of myself and trying to be a healthy, firm woman. I am 26 years old. I don’t know if you can help me. The last counselor I went to told me that this happened because I was sinful. I AM sinful. But this runs in another vein. Can you give me any steps to become healthy again?

Answer: I am so sorry that your counseling experience wasn’t more helpful and that one of your counselors even told you it this happened to you because of your own sin. It reminds me of one of Job’s friends. Job didn’t find that kind of advice helpful either.

I want you to think about a few things that might provide a roadmap toward your continued healing.

You wrote that this happened over a year ago and he stalked you for eight months. That’s not much time to heal from this kind of trauma. Help me understand what makes you feel stuck? What would be different about you right now if you were healed and functioning like a healthy 26 year old? You say that’s what you’re trying to do but what does that look like to you? Write it down.

The writer of Ecclesiastes wrote, “there is a time to break down” but he added that there is “a time to build up. A time to weep, and a time to laugh; a time to mourn, and a time to dance; a time to cast away stones, and a time to gather stones together ( Ecclesiastes 3:3-5 ). Give yourself enough time to process what happened before feeling impatient with your healing.

[Tweet “Sometimes people find that the worst of times also become the seed bed for the best of times.”] Although for each person it may take a different amount of time, somewhere in looking at our past problems and even current suffering we need to rise out of the rubble in order to not only cope with what has happened to us, but begin to thrive again.

This is where you start to have a say in what kind of story you are writing about your life. We don’t always understand that we play a very significant role in our own healing process. We can’t always control what happens to us (as you have experienced first hand), but if we want to mature and become healthy people, we must decide what we do with what happen to us. This is the most important part of your story. You get to choose how you are going to respond to this adversity and pain. As the victim or as the hero?

Let me give you a few things you can start to do right now which is taken from chapter 10 in my book, Lord I Just Want to be Happy.

Look for the Meaning or Purpose: While chained in prison, the apostle Paul wrote of a very difficult experience and said that it served to advance the gospel ( Philippians 1:12-13 ). Paul felt real pain and suffering, but his pain was put in perspective by understanding some of God’s purposes in it. I want you to write about what happened to you for 15 minutes for four consecutive days. But don’t write to vent. As you write, look to make sense of the causes and consequences of what happened. Every day dig a little deeper to extract the diamonds from the rubble. Write a new ending to an old story or close a chapter on an open wound. Let yourself see it in a new way.

Look for the Benefits: When going through a tough time, three questions you can ask yourself that can help you endure and rise are:

  1. What strengths have I discovered in myself, or have the opportunity to develop?
  2. What lessons have I learned?
  3. What have I overcome through this?

Write about these things. Recognize that your experience wasn’t wasted. [Tweet “You will be a stronger person not in spite of, but because of what happened to you.”] The apostle Paul reminds us that “We also rejoice in our sufferings, because we know that suffering produces perseverance; perseverance, character; and character, hope” ( Romans 5:3-4 ).

Look for the Good: Although what happened to you was bad, if you look hard you might be able to find some elements of good to it. A woman who had recently lost her son in a tragic accident told me, “I’m thankful he didn’t suffer. I’m thankful he died doing something he loved. I’m grateful for so many friends who are helping me through this time of loss.”

Although this woman suffered the loss of her only child, looking for the good helped her move through it in a better way than if she only looked at all the negative things.

Much of how we feel about life comes from the way we look at it. Consider this poem by Frederick Langbridge:

Two men look out the same prison bars.

One sees mud, and the other stars.

Both men were in prison, mud and stars were equally present, but the man who focused on the stars felt happier than the man who only saw mud. You may feel like your life is a prison and that you have a life sentence. There is no erasing your circumstances or what happened to you but how respond to them and see them now will impact your levels of well-being, not only emotionally, but mentally, spiritually, relationally, and physically.

I want you to understand that suffering can take two tracks. Formative suffering and deformative suffering. Formative suffering is important. It helps us grieve our losses and deal with our pain. It is used by God to teach us what’s important and to help us grow up and let go of foolish things. Formative suffering helps us find God and our true selves instead of losing our way through life with temporal delights and deceptive thinking. Formative suffering is part of living in a sinful and broken world. Things are not as they should be.

Deformative suffering is our poor response to suffering. It rises out of our unrealistic expectations, the lies we believe, our bad habits, and our negative emotions such as self-pity, envy, greed, jealousy, resentment, unforgiveness, pride, and shame.

Don’t short circuit the formative suffering you’re experiencing through this event. But be mindful that it’s a very short walk into deformative suffering because we can’t let go, see the good, control negative thoughts or emotions or forgive the people who hurt us.

Try these suggestions as your next few steps and let me know how you’re doing.

Friend, how have you taken control of a story that you didn’t like, but didn’t want to stay powerless or helpless in the midst of it? What did you learn? What was the “before” and “after” once you decided to take back your personal power of deciding how your main character (YOU) were going to walk through your story?

Have you heard about the BRAND NEW group coaching program?


This small group coaching program is the culmination of 25 years of private practice and hundreds of hours helping women just like you.


  1. DN on April 28, 2021 at 10:15 am

    I’m choosing to heal. By counseling, safe friends, support group, Conquer support on line and Conquer material.
    Choosing to intentionally grieve. Setting time to journal.
    I’m learning to process my anger . Today it hit me how my husband who is no more took advantage of me. Said that way spoke more to me than betrayal yet it falls under betrayal. He took advantage of my good qualities, my dreams, hopes, commitment, love, compassionate.
    As I grieved that I rejoice that I had and still have those good qualities. He squashed them but they are not gone. The Lord is giving me others to live and care for.
    I encourage the 26 yr old who has been used fir her kindness and believers telling her to keep being kind to a man who disregards her that she is still the kind young vibrant girl. Yes we are more guarded but for me that’s another good thing from my abuse marriage.
    God has taught me I can emotionally protect myself.
    He loves me and rescued me out of destruction.

    • JoAnn on April 28, 2021 at 6:49 pm

      Good work, DN. You are on a path to healing. Thanks for sharing.

  2. Susan on April 28, 2021 at 3:14 pm

    I so identify with your story and my heart breaks knowing you are going through a devastating time trying to recover from something similar to what I experienced. A horrible stalking experience effected my life for yrs. I saw numerous counselors over the years. I personally “worked” on myself researching and trying to apply everything I could find. I was able to function well on a daily basis and succeed in life but had issues with depression, self esteem, etc that plagued me for decades. None of the counselors, even a few who work with people in abusive relationships, were able to help and I was in despair thinking I would never heal from this experience. Here is what I discovered. The reason I experienced the same symptoms that you described so well, for so many years, was because my experience was trauma. The trauma effected every aspect of my being deeply – mind, body and Spirit. None of the counselors I saw over the years identified my experience as trauma and none had trauma informed training. I could have spent the rest of my life “working” on myself, applying principles and seeing counselors. But when I identified the real problem as trauma, found a trauma informed counselor and a brilliant Christian trauma informed teacher and course, things began to change. I had to learn how to allow the Holy Spirit to infiltrate these past experiences and process them in the presence of the Lord. Learning to forgive, grieve the losses, rebuild my identity in Christ, leading to healing and wholeness, have become the reality I had feared I would never know. It is amazing the amount of shame that was associated with this past experience with an aggressive, highly skilled manipulator at a time when I was very vulnerable. I was plagued by shame, blame and self doubt. I felt disconnected and deeply flawed and thought there was something terribly wrong with me. But I’ve faced every aspect of this traumatic experience including understanding why I was susceptible and such an easy target for this individual in the first place. The counseling and the exercises I applied over the years were not a waste of time bc each step helped in some way, The problem was in not addressing the real core issue of trauma and a lack of understanding about what it takes for some of us to heal from this . Techniques can make changes bc our brains are neuroplastic and respond well by creating new pathways but they did not change my heart and result in a fruit bearing life. My heart began to repair, heal and become whole when I learned how to allow the Holy Spirit to repair and rebuild my identity in Christ. I don’t know how extreme your experience was and what will be the key for you but Hoping you find the healing and wholeness the Lord desires for each of as you take the steps forward in the healing process.

    • JoAnn on April 29, 2021 at 10:39 am

      Susan, thank you for sharing your experience. I’m sorry it took so long to get the right “diagnosis,” but once you did, healing could begin. I like that you said, ” My heart began to repair, heal and become whole when I learned how to allow the Holy Spirit to repair and rebuild my identity in Christ.” Wonderful! Praise Him!

Leave a Comment

Ask Your Question

Have a blog question you'd like to submit?

Read More

How Do I Talk About My Ex-Husband With the Kids?

Question: I left my ex-husband 10 years ago because of his abusive behavior toward myself and my oldest child. The children have had to maintain court-ordered relationship with him. My son was older and he has been able to maintain his dad at a safe distance. Our daughter was always his little princess. She has…


How do explain my ex-husband’s behavior to our kids without making him look bad?

  Morning friends, Prayers needed. Each morning of this week, I am writing for four to five hours before starting my counseling schedule. My clients have graciously agreed to come in the afternoon all week so that I can have my best writing time free. Please pray that God would give me wisdom and flow…


Can I Thrive with a Spouse That Is Incapable of Meeting My Needs?

Welcome to June, my friends! This month, I have chosen to explore the virtue of resilience. Resilience is intricately woven into the fabric of nature, as evidenced by the mighty oak tree withstanding fierce winds and the delicate flower blooming against all odds. Just as nature embraces resilience, we too can find the strength within…