Question: Do you ever recommend withholding sex as a consequence for destructive behavior? Laura in FL
Answer: I don’t recommend a spouse withhold sex anymore than I would recommend that he or she withhold talking when angry. Touching and talking are the only channels that intimacy is expressed and experienced. If someone cuts off those channels when they are angry, hurt or disappointed in their spouse, then you might as well toss away the marriage relationship. Using sex as a weapon is like using the silent treatment as a weapon. It isn’t good for the marriage. It is controlling and manipulative.
The one exception I would make is when someone is unsure of the sexual faithfulness of his or her spouse. Then the person might wisely choose abstain from sex until safety and fidelity issues are resolved.
That said, loving intimacy might be absent in a marriage at times, just like good conversation, but not as a punishment. For example, telling your spouse “I can’t talk right now because I’m too angry to talk constructively or because you won’t listen to me”, isn’t using silence as a weapon but stating a problem in the relationship. In the same way, if someone says, “I can’t have sexual closeness with you right now because I’m too angry to do it lovingly” may be absolutely true. Or telling a partner, “I feel like I’m just a sex object to you when you disrespect me at other times”, helps the one who is doing the hurting to know what needs to change in order to repair the relationship.
There a more extensive answer as to how to talk about this issue with a destructive spouse in the Blog Question: Do I Have to Have Sex with My Abusive Husband?
Leave a Comment
Ask Your Question
Have a blog question you'd like to submit?
Topic: Do I forbear or confront when someone offends me?
Hello everyone, What a beautiful day we have today. It’s been such a cold, dreary, winter. The sun is out today, the temperature is beautiful and I have begun a new adventure. My husband has always loved riding motorcycles. After our children were grown he bought himself a Harley but I always felt afraid riding…
How do I talk with my husband when he’s always right?
Hi Friends, I know, I know, I haven’t posted my Alaska pictures yet. Some of you have gone to see them and have been disappointed. I’m sorry. I am not computer savvy yet and I confess – I don’t remember how to do it. My secretary was swamped with other things and so I couldn’t…
Am I Being Stupid Or Nice
Morning friend, Christmas 2022 has passed, and a New Year is right around the corner. What will you do to make 2023 different? This week, the time between what’s old and what’s new invites reflection. What am I letting go of? What do I want to take hold of? This morning I asked God 3…
Of course it’s okay to set your boundaries. If telling him that sex is not on the agenda then so be it. It depends on the circumstances. You can’t really answer this if you don’t know what is going on. This shows the futility of asking questions like this on someone’s blog on the internet.